Wednesday, June 17, 2015
Eastern Ukraine: Look Beyond Mainstream Propaganda
It's always interesting for me to observe the reaction of Americans and Western Europeans when they learn where I'm from. Many just don't say anything. Many regurgitate something incoherent about Putin's "imperial" ambitions, "the Boeing" that was shot down over Eastern Ukraine last year, and "that politician guy that got killed in Moscow." Finally, there are those (unfortunately, a minority) who tell me that things must be more complicated than they are portrayed in the news and genuinely want to know what I think.
Things are definitely much more complicated than they're portrayed in the news. I've had a chance to observe mainstream American, Canadian, and British media for quite some time now, and I'm amazed that so few people are appalled by the crudeness of propaganda that is fed to them, no matter whether the source is Fox News, CNN, or the BBC. Just like that Wal-Mart truck driver that stopped to help a stranded motorist doesn't make Wal-Mart a great place to shop, the Pentagon Papers don't make The New York Times a progressive newspaper. Neither does covering the Snowden case make The Guardian a source you should now trust and worship.
When I can hear explosions in the background in the middle of a phone conversation with my relatives who are hunkering down with their young children in the hallway of their apartment ("safe" because it's away from the windows) while being shelled by Ukrainian artillery, and the "progressive" sources mentioned above pontificate about Russia's "aggression" in Ukraine, call for more sanctions, and do not say a word about the massive devastation and suffering the US- and Europe-backed regime in Kiev has caused in just one year in one of the most urbanized parts of Europe, I feel disappointment and helplessness. Do these talking heads have no shame? Do those who listen to them have no brain? Opportunities to question, explore, and learn are all around you. Why not use them?
How many of you know that the cities of Donetsk (once home to over one million people) and Gorlovka (Horlivka; once home to more than 300 thousand people) have been shelled by the Ukrainian military pretty much daily throughout the month of May and in the first half of June - despite the so-called ceasefire?
How many of you know that American soldiers are actually in Ukraine training the Ukrainian National Guard - the troops that are then deployed to the East of the country? (Do a quick search, and even your "trustworthy" mainstream sources will confirm that - in a non-intrusive sort of way, of course.)
How many of you remember the context of Victoria Nuland's "Fuck the EU" comment in her conversation with the US ambassador to Ukraine Geoffrey Pyatt?
How many of you know that John Brennan, director of the CIA, visited Ukraine in April of last year, immediately after which Ukraine's "counter-terrorist operation" began in the rebellious East of the country? (Do another quick search, and your "trustworthy" mainstream sources will again confirm that - also in a non-intrusive sort of way.)
How many of you can imagine Russia putting its navy ships in the Gulf of Mexico, installing an anti-American regime in Canada, and holding military exercises just south of the US-Mexican border? How many of you can imagine what the American reaction to that would be? How ridiculous would the EU look if it imposed sanctions on the US? (Well, the EU looks just as ridiculous with all its current posturing and double standards.)
How many of you can imagine US and European sanctions against Saudi Arabia for its actions in Yemen? How many of your "trustworthy" sources use the word "aggression" when describing Saudi Arabia's actions?
It took crash investigators a few days to learn what was going on in and around the cockpit of Germanwings Flight 9525, which crashed over the Alps less than three months ago. How many of you wonder what ever happened to the black boxes of the Malasia Airlines Flight 17 now that almost a year has passed since the plane was shot down over Ukraine? (It seemed so clear whom to blame back then, didn't it?)
You most definitely heard about "that politician guy that got killed in Moscow." How many of you know about a whole number of "politician guys" that have "committed suicide" in Ukraine? Other than stumbling on an occasional blurb (http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/apr/15/ousted-ukraine-president-ally-shot-dead), you'd really have to look to see what's going on.
How many of you know about Oles Buzina, a pro-Russian journalist, who got murdered in Kiev just two months ago?
Finally, have you ever wondered who actually benefits from this war in Ukraine? Do you really think it's Russia, now stuck with hundreds of thousands of refugees from Ukraine, a rabidly russophobic regime next door, and NATO bristling with all its fancy glory literally on Russia's borders? Is it the "separatists" (or Ukrainians alike), whose most industrialized region is now in ruins? Or is there perhaps another party that's meddling in all this? Use your imagination. May curiosity be your friend.